• Home
  • Our Story
  • Clients
  • Candidates
  • Blog
  • KHS Perspective
  • Contact
KHS People
  • Home
  • Our Story
  • Clients
  • Candidates
  • Blog
  • KHS Perspective
  • Contact

Our blog

When recruiting senior marketing & BD professionals, overhaul these 3 recruiting practices

3/5/2020

 
Recruiting practices should be evaluated at regular intervals. They should be relevant to the professional being interviewed and responsive to the market. 

Here are three recruiting practices that should be overhauled when recruiting senior marketing and BD professionals into your firms. “Senior” here means the marketing and BD professionals who spend the majority of their time on strategy and management, namely, Manager, Senior Manager, Director and CMO.

  1. The “writing test”. This is typically a practice that has been in place for many years and no one has questioned why. I frequently hear the marketing and BD team leaders who are hiring say its “an HR requirement” without understanding why or questioning its relevance. In that case, below I offer some different ways to come at this. Keep in mind that testing a candidate on attention to detail and proof-reading (if indeed that’s the objective of this test) can be done in different ways, particularly at the senior levels. Most senior marketing and BD professionals - and rightly so in my view - will get offended when asked to sit a writing test. Juniors will anticipate this step. Seniors will not and will wonder why it's being asked of them.
  2. The “middle man” test. Many firms put a non-marketing or BD professional, often a junior HR representative, in front of the marketing and BD professional as a first step. Again, at the junior levels, this can be a sensible step. But the more senior the role, the more the firm should adapt and equally offer up a senior marketing or BD professional at the first conversation.
  3.  “Tell us a time when…” test. Aka the behavioral questions. The secret was out a long time ago; applicants can train for and anticipate these questions. This creates the problem of hiring a marketer or BD’er primarily because they are good at interviewing. It doesn’t automatically follow that they are also really good at their role. The other issue with these questions is that they typically start from a negative place and assume the worst: “…you’ve missed a deadline / had a conflict with a partner / received negative feedback?” What if the candidate hasn’t missed a deadline, how do they answer this? Is it establishing the right relationship by expecting an applicant to share their failings without any kind of rapport being established?

Consider these alternatives:
​
  • Instead of the writing test: Ask the candidate about a marketing or BD initiative where they have been the main instigator or driver. Get them talking about how the project came about, what they contributed and how they moved the needle on the firms’ marketing ROI. Once you understand this context, you will have a feel for what documentation may have supported this project. Ask if they would feel comfortable sharing that (it’s assumed these documents are kept confidential). Most written pieces are a collaborative effort and are done with the luxury of more than 45 minutes, which is the typical writing test length. Unless you’re hiring a PR, external relations or crisis communications professional, the timed writing test doesn’t provide the answers you’re looking for.
  • Instead of the middle man: If you have 20 candidates to interview for a senior marketing or BD role and don’t have a spare 20 hours in your week, you will need assistance from your HR team. But, most hiring managers of senior marketing and BD roles are only interviewing a fraction of this number. So, it should be that person making that initial judgment and – wait for it – marketing and selling the role to the right candidates. Additionally, in recent years (and this is a trend that will continue), marketers at every level are astute and informed. They have just as many questions for you as are being asked of them. Whoever is at each interview phase should be equipped to answer those questions. I have worked with HR professionals who know the marketing and BD team intimately and offer great value and time-saving by being the initial face to the candidate. But, this is not typically the norm.
  • Instead of the behavioral questions: Ask questions that matter and that reveal the information you need to know. If you ask a question about a time when they successfully avoided a partner conflict situation they will likely be able to share the "textbook" answer (regardless of their actual experience) for diffusing a conflictual situation. And keep in mind that it's more common than not for people to avoid conflict altogether. Instead, consider more meaningful interview questions. KHS People has developed literally dozens of questions geared to truly illuminate candidates’ skills and value. Three are shared below:
  1. What two lessons would you share with your younger self to help you navigate working within a partnership structure in order to move the needle on BD?
  2. What marketing and BD projects fall within your remit that you believe are not adding any ROI? What would you do instead?
  3. What sort of management style works best for you to support your growth?
​
Recruiting the senior marketing and BD professionals that are the right fit for both firm and individual is a challenge for any CMO or marketing team leader. Having the right process in place makes this much easier. It also makes you and your team and firm look qualified to be hiring the senior professional that you are. 

Part II – Best practices for recruiting marketing & BD people into your firm

8/28/2018

 
Best practice recruiting involves two things: a sound strategy, and good execution of that strategy.

Earlier this year I outlined an approach to ensure best practices are applied when recruiting the interpersonal roles of professional services marketing and BD people. I now share some key factors to help implement that approach.
​
Recap on strategy
             
By way of a quick cap, an effective best practice recruiting approach to attract the right marketing and BD professionals includes:  
  • Conduct meetings, not interviews
  • Plan out the meetings
  • Set your candidate’s expectations
  • Include the key people from the start
  • Have one meeting out of the office
  • Ask questions that give you the right information
 
Effective execution

Here are some ways you can ensure effective execution of this approach. Keep in mind that all of these require only minimal planning, and will ensure a seamless, sophisticated and thorough interview meeting process for all involved:

  • Assign different questions and discussion points. There will likely be marketing and BD team leaders, HR professionals, and partners all involved in these meetings. Whoever is coordinating the touchpoints with a candidate should assign different questions and discussion points between these people. This ensures candidates aren’t being asked the same question multiple times throughout. And importantly, you can learn more about your candidate as each question will have a different focus, allowing you to gain a complete picture of the candidate.
  • Consider the logistics. Consider any interruptions to the meeting process. For example, who is going on vacation and can’t participate, who is traveling to other offices and will be hard to reach and follow up with, and who is simply too busy. Plan this going in, and then talk to your candidate about the logistics and timing.
  • Who is assigned with the follow up. Someone needs to take the lead on communicating with the candidate. Particularly when there’s marketing, BD, HR and partners all involved, often everyone assumes someone else has the lead. The candidate deserves to have a central point of contact and also to understand where they are at in the process. I see too frequently candidates getting disengaged from the process as the firm forgets to do these simple updates. And that’s when candidates will look to other firms who do have these best practices in place.
  • Interview training. Most people don’t conduct interviews as a part of their daily lives. Particularly partners in law and accounting firms. When people are not used to conducting interview meetings, they can be unnatural or overly formal. Others mask their own unfamiliarity with either aggressive tactics or by talking too much. The role of the firm here is to prepare people who will be speaking with the candidate on how to conduct an interview meeting. It should involve these things: information gathering, information sharing, testing on technical abilities, and cultural alignment discussion points. Attempting to ‘catch the candidate out’, or proving you know more than them aren’t conducive to an effective interview meeting.
  • Formal v informal. Hopefully time permits for you to have one interview meeting out of the office. Mirror the circumstances of these meetings with your style. For example, an in-office formal interview meeting will naturally be more structured. An out of the office coffee meeting should be deliberately more casual, trying to build rapport and get a sense of who the candidate is as a person. Find out what they do outside of work, what community efforts they’re involved in, what sports they like to play. All of this tells you more about the candidate and who they will be each day in the office.
  • Share as much as you ask. Candidates often have just as many questions as you do. They have thought at length about the potential of the opportunity (and how it fits with their personal career goals), your team structure, the firm leadership, and the future goals and trajectory of the firm. Don’t make the mistake of thinking these meetings are just for you to gather information. Purposefully make a point of allowing a good amount of time to ask them what you can share with them.
 
Summing up     
 
Interview meetings, and the whole process of conducting these meetings, is not easily done. There’s planning, logistics and effective execution to all happen at the right time. But importantly, you, at your firms, have to judge a candidate and make a call about whether they are right for you while they are doing the same in return. If you follow this approach and execute effectively, this hard decision does become a little easier. Make it as easy as you can: arm yourself with the right information and plan accordingly, involve the right people, and ask the right questions. You will then feel fully informed to make the right decision. 

6 interview best practices for marketing & BD candidates

2/21/2018

 
​Best practice recruiting involves two things: a sound strategy and good execution of that strategy.
​
Applying recruiting best practices to the interpersonal roles of marketing and BD has never been more important. Rarely are personal attributes - from one’s style, approach and energy - as on display as they are in these roles. Marketing and BD roles are influential and highly visible, as they deal with many people each and every day. Getting someone who can have a positive interaction with each person at every turn is essential.

Many firms struggle to find the right people. A best practice helps to professionally and purposefully recruit the right marketing and BD people for your team and your firm.

This blog focuses on the first part of that best practice, namely, the strategy or plan. In a follow up blog, I will discuss how to effectively execute on that plan.
 
Part 1: An effective strategy                 

  • Conduct meetings, not interviews. Calling it an interview makes people nervous. When people are nervous their most natural self is not on display. This means technical abilities become masked by unnecessary nervousness, and softer skills get misinterpreted. For those who argue that it’s good to see how candidates act under pressure, I would say “yes, and…” there are very few situations in a firm which are the same as an interview. And I argue there are better ways to test their abilities under pressure (and I’ll elaborate on this further below).
  • Plan out the meetings. This is so simple to do, but many miss the mark. Take a few minutes to map out what the meeting process will look like. This includes how long it will take (how many phases of meetings will you conduct?), who is involved at each phase (do you need some or all of your peers, partners, and HR involved?), and when will you be able to get feedback from others involved at each phase to move forward (who’s out on vacation or who’s simply too busy to contribute meaningfully and quickly?).
  • Set your candidate’s expectations. Take a few minutes at each meeting with your candidates to communicate timing, actions and next steps. This shows that you are recruiting for the role in a meaningful and professional way and that you have a clear path forward. Ending a meeting with “thanks we’ll be in touch” is vague and indecisive and risks miscommunicating your intentions about their candidacy and your next steps. Candidates understand they’re usually not the only person being considered for the role, they just want transparency about the process and timing.
  • Key people from the start. An effective process needs the key people from the start so the right people are talking and no time is wasted. This means the person who will manage this candidate should be the first person who meets with them. These days, we – as recruiters – have done all the qualifying for you so you can fast-track any introductory or process driven meetings and get straight to the higher value conversations and what you’re trying to achieve.
  • Have one meeting out of the office. Outside interactions show you how your candidate interacts with and treats others and how they hold themselves outside of the firm. How often have you observed someone reacting or being abrupt to someone, only to then quickly revert back to their ‘other self’ with the people they are with. True characters are revealed in situations of uncertainty, stress or uneasiness. Take your candidate out for a coffee or lunch and watch and observe. An added bonus to this phase is you get to build a deeper rapport than normal; which is essential if you end up working together.
  • Ask questions that give you the right information. This is a topic in and of itself. But, at a high level, rather than fall into the script of asking them to count the number of times they’ve done a certain project or task, change the emphasis to elicit a response that tells you how they react in certain situations. This goes to their past behavior (the best indicator of future behavior) and shows you how they deal with people and circumstances. This includes how they learn or adapt, how they delegate, and how they manage their boss, peers and juniors. The answers you receive will give you a read on their technical abilities, their all-important softer skills, their people management abilities, and their cultural fit; all equally important. All of this information also gives you insights into their ability to problem solve under pressure.
 
Moving forward                        
 
Use the above six-point strategy when you next need to hire. And then compare it with your old method to see where you noticed the value. Adding the right people to your team and to the future of your firm is the most important thing you can do. Commit to the strategy and have confidence that it yields the best results.

    Author

    Kate Harry Shipham is the Principal of KHS People LLC, an executive search firm for BD and marketing people in professional services firms. Kate has done search and recruiting for 10 years and prior to that was an attorney. She loves what she does, and is always open to continuing the discussion: kate@khspeople.com

    Categories

    All
    Best Practices
    Client-centric
    Covid-19
    Giving Thanks
    How To Hire
    In House Insights
    Interviews
    Job Descriptions
    Podcasts
    Prof Dev
    Projections
    Quick Bites
    Resumes
    Salary
    Surveys
    Telling Your Story
    The Offer Stage
    Tight Labor Market
    Titles
    When To Hire
    White Papers
    Why People Move

    Archives

    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018

    RSS Feed

© COPYRIGHT 2017-2021 KHS People LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • Our Story
  • Clients
  • Candidates
  • Blog
  • KHS Perspective
  • Contact